Skip to main content

BOOK REVIEW : WITHOUT A GOODBYE




What is it about a mother that manages to move us everytime? Swati Kumari’s debut novel “Without A Goodbye” answers this question convincingly.

When I read the title of the novel, I assumed it would be yet another love story. But I was thankfully proven wrong when I read the synopsis.

PLOT

The story describes the poignant tale of Danica and her mother Aarti, depicting both their lives in detail. Danica is all set to appear for her competitive exams in Patna. She has a talk with her mother before going inside the exam hall. However after she comes out, she is unable to contact her mother. 

The entire family searches for her, but she just seems to have vanished. What happened to her? Where did she go? Is she alive or not? These questions trouble everyone, before finally the truth is revealed. What was the truth and what circumstances led to it forms the crux of the story.


WRITING

Well, the author keeps the language pretty simple. Infact at times the language is so simple that it could have been a bit more on the higher side. Swati maintains a first person record throughout the book – first as herself, later describing Danica’s account and inbetween her mother’s story. This idea of narrating everyone’s story in her own point of view is very well done.

POSITIVES

I liked the basic plot of the story. Unlike all the novels these days who, taking a cue from Chetan Bhagat, are writing shitty love stories, this novel is a welcome change. It is a love story, but between a mother and a daughter.

One more thing I liked is the detailing. The bond between Danica and her mother is not the routine mother – daughter bond. It is a much more intimate bond, the intimacy escalated due to a failed marriage. When the man of the house is the bad guy, the woman automatically tends to get more close to her children – it is human tendency. And that is depicted pretty well by Swati.

Swati also displays emotions well. There is never an overdose of anything – be it joy or sorrow. She shows how people react under normal circumstances, sans any exaggeration. There are times when something terrible happens to you, but you are so dazed that you don’t understand whether to cry or shout. Swati depicts such situations in the book very deftly.

The ending is one more thing I loved. Although filmy, it provides the needed boost towards the end. It reaffirms our faith in goodness.


NEGATIVES

As I mentioned, the language is pretty simple. But at times, it is very amateurish. There are even grammatical errors. They are minor ones but need correction.

Also, Swati depicts this whole joint family in too detail. For those who are used to it, this is not a problem, but for many, it might get confusing. At times, I found it difficult to catch up with all the characters. There are too many mama-mamis, masa-masis, etc.


OVERALL

Overall, “Without a goodbye” is definitely a book worth reading. It is a light read and describes the mother – daughter bond beautifully. I definitely felt proud of my parents while reading this book.

Also, this is a book with which many moms and many daughters will be able to relate.
It is a story which only a woman could have penned. Good job Swati Kumari. 

Comments

  1. you write for you is good but, it better for context us..the human..todays writes only give their option like politician,only her /his problem is big some time every one have different problem which create new story.. every story is not

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

TANU WEDS MANU RETURNS : MY THOUGHTS

THIS POST CONTAINS SPOILERS. IT IS TO BE READ ONLY IF YOU HAVE WATCHED THE MOVIE. IT IS NOT EXACTLY A REVIEW. IT CONTAINS THOUGHTS ABOUT HOW I LIKED THE MOVIE. IT IS LONG AND CONTAINS QUITE SOME IMAGES. Few facts we learnt from Tanu Weds Manu Returns – 1.      Southhall mein logon ke ghar ke baahar kacchhe sookhte hain. 2.      Tharki logon ki pasandeeda kitaab hain “LOLITA” 3.      “TILANDI” means “VANISHED” 4.      Tanu saves her husband Manu’s number in her phone under the contact name “HUSBAND” 5.      Delhi ka aadha pollution aashiqon ki wajah se hain. 6.      “JHAND” means “DESTROYED” 7.      “PEEPNI” means … “Bachpan mein buddha hota than a neeli aankhon waala, jisse pichkaao toh         aawaaz aati thi PEE PEE” 8.      Pappi ki colony ki do nikkar wali ladkiyon ne use propose ...

BARFI! - MY THOUGHTS (A PICTORIAL RECOLLECTION)

Indian cinema has always had a strong desire to portray disabilities on screen. While 99% of such films are dull and message oriented, there are a few directors who prove that such people don’t always mean gloom. And so we have Anurag Basu taking us in the life of Murphy. For three hours he transports us into a world which is literally a fairy tale. Such is the beauty of the final product that I actually felt like not leaving the cinema hall; staying a little more in Barfi and Jhilmil’s world. Have you ever felt irritated by the beginning credits of a film? The ones which go like – “Special thanks to…”, “Media partners”, “Publicity partners“, and the names of thousand other brands which might have played a miniscule role in the film? But in Barfi, you never realize when all that finished. Reason? “PICTURE SHURUUUU…. HO GAYI PICTURE SHURU….” This was innovation at its cinematic best. Swanand Kirkire’s witty and apt lines in his own voice make us rapt with attent...

MY REVIEW OF MIRZAPUR SEASON 2

I was a late entrant into the "Mirzapur" weries. Even though it arrived 2 years back, I watched it only a couple of months back during the lockdown. I finally gave in to the immense pressure around, and I couldn’t resist seeing what was so great about the show which led it to become the most successful series in India. And hence, I started watching the first episode of season 1. Shuru majboori mein kiye they, par baad mein jo majaa aaya, I can't describe that. I realized that the hype around the show was totally justified. Also, the makers ended season 1 on such a cliffhanger that it was imperative for everyone to wait so eagerly for season 2. PLOT, DIRECTION & WRITING As I started watching season 2,I slowly realized a few things. This season was way different from the previous one. Gone was the rawness and loudness. The amount of violence shown also seemed much less. Things seemed much more mature. My thoughts were only strengthened as I progressed further.  Season 2...